For a brief and exhilarating period in the 2010s, cinephiles were living the dream thanks to MoviePass. The service, which allowed subscribers to watch one movie per day for a modest monthly fee, seemed too good to be true. As Muta’Ali’s documentary “MoviePass, MovieCrash” reveals, it was indeed unsustainable. The company’s journey from startup darling to cautionary tale is both fascinating and tragic.
MoviePass started with a simple yet ambitious idea. Pay $9.95 a month and see up to thirty movies. It was a dream come true for movie lovers but a nightmare for accountants. The business model, which relied on subscribers using a prepaid debit card to buy movie tickets, quickly proved financially untenable. The documentary delves into the reasons behind this flawed strategy and the idealistic employees who were caught in the crossfire.
Muta’Ali finds a compelling angle by focusing on the personal stories of the company’s founders, Stacy Spikes and Hamet Watt. These two Black entrepreneurs had a vision to save the movie theater experience through a subscription model. Their sensible and innovative approach, however, was undermined by the very investors who were supposed to support them. The film highlights how Spikes and Watt’s idea was co-opted and ultimately destroyed by greed and mismanagement.
The heart of the story lies in the conflict between the original founders and the new management. Spikes and Watt are portrayed as earnest and visionary, while Mitch Lowe and Ted Farnsworth, who took over the company, are depicted as reckless and greedy. Lowe and Farnsworth’s decision to offer the too-good-to-be-true $10/month subscription led to a rapid increase in subscribers but also accelerated the company’s financial collapse.
“MoviePass, MovieCrash” covers a lot of ground, from the initial excitement and rapid growth to the chaotic and ultimately destructive decisions made by the new leadership. The documentary includes interviews with former employees and subscribers, who reflect on the company’s rise and fall with a mix of nostalgia and frustration. There are amusing anecdotes, such as the ill-fated marketing stunt at Coachella featuring Dennis Rodman, that add color to the narrative.
While the documentary is informative, it occasionally falls into familiar patterns. The structure relies heavily on talking head interviews and archival footage, which can feel repetitive. Some transitions between the different phases of the company’s history are awkward, and the use of animations to illustrate financial data is somewhat crude. Despite these flaws, the film maintains a compelling narrative.
One of the documentary’s strengths is its exploration of the broader themes of entrepreneurial racism and the systemic challenges faced by Black entrepreneurs. The film positions MoviePass as not just a business failure but a symbol of how innovative ideas can be crushed by predatory practices. This angle adds depth to the story, making it more than just a tale of corporate mismanagement.
The film’s climax reveals a glimmer of hope. In 2021, Stacy Spikes managed to buy back the company and plans to revive it with a more sustainable approach. This development, however, feels like an afterthought in the documentary, which spends more time dissecting the failures than exploring the potential for a successful reboot.
“MoviePass, MovieCrash” is a thought-provoking documentary that offers valuable insights into the perils of unchecked ambition and the challenges of entrepreneurship. It’s a must-watch for anyone interested in business, innovation, and the movie industry. The film serves as a reminder that even the best ideas need careful stewardship to succeed.
Watch “MoviePass, MovieCrash” on Max now and join the conversation about the rise and fall of one of the most ambitious startups in recent history.
Visit Hitplay for more insightful movie reviews and updates.
