“Conclave,” a gripping film based on Robert Harris’ 2016 novel, delves into the secretive world of the papal election at the Vatican. The film’s intricate depiction of behind-the-scenes lobbying raises the question: How much of it is true? David Gibson, Director of the Center on Religion and Culture at Fordham University, sheds some light on the subject. According to Gibson, real-life papal contenders do engage in quiet campaigning. However, they must tread carefully; overt ambition could cost them crucial votes. As highlighted in Gibson’s insights shared with GQ, this delicate balance between ambition and humility mirrors the film’s storyline, earning it a 93% rating on Rotten Tomatoes.
In Gibson’s interview, he reveals the complexities of a real conclave. “He who enters the conclave a pope, leaves it a cardinal,” underscores the irony that those seen as favorites often fall short. Cardinals must rely on allies to promote their candidacy subtly, lest they appear too eager. Realistically, about 15 to 20 cardinals are considered potential successors. Unlike past centuries when the outcome was more predictable, modern conclaves can see wild cards, as evidenced by the election of Pope John XXIII in 1958 and the unpredicted rise of Pope Francis.
The film “Conclave” captures these dynamics through characters like Cardinal Bellini, Cardinal Tremblay, and Cardinal Tedesco, each shown with ambitious streaks and a cadre of followers advocating on their behalf. Despite their initial appeal, their ambition is seen as a double-edged sword. The protagonist, Cardinal Lawrence, played by Ralph Fiennes, observes these power plays while wrestling with accusations of his own ambition. Ultimately, the chosen pontiff emerges from the ranks of those perceived as less politically driven—maintaining a veneer of selflessness that swayed his peers.
“Conclave” doesn’t just deliver drama; it gives audiences a peek behind the Vatican’s curtains, showing a process shrouded in secrecy yet deeply human. With direction by Edward Berger and a stellar cast including Stanley Tucci and John Lithgow, the film crafts an authentic narrative bolstered by Gibson’s insider perspective. Reviews affirm its success, with thoughtful portrayals and realistic intrigue that resonate well with critics and audiences alike.
The movie’s authenticity and gripping performances seem to explain why it is so well-received. As Gibson’s analysis suggests, the realism of political maneuvering is skillfully captured in “Conclave,” offering viewers a rare and engaging glimpse into one of the world’s most secretive processes.
Closing Credits
“Conclave,” set to release on October 25, 2024, presents a compelling tapestry of faith, ambition, and politics. Its meticulous attention to detail not only entertains but educates, supported by experts like David Gibson. As the film continues to receive acclaim, it stands as a shining example of how cinema can intrigue and enlighten viewers about hidden corners of world events. Whether you’re a history buff or just looking for a well-crafted drama, “Conclave” promises to be a thought-provoking watch.
